Skip to content
Reviewed by Petra Verbeek DP Hamilton Christian School Waikato
Opening sentence
Mine is not to reason why.
In Jenny Davis's poignant novel, readers are drawn into a narrative that seamlessly weaves together elements of fiction and non-fiction, creating a compelling tale of courage, friendship, and resilience.

I loved Davis's storytelling; her vivid language and descriptive imagery bring the story to life. She juxtaposes beauty and brutality, tackling difficult themes with grace and sensitivity. Scenes, such as the 'rape of the Hong Kong nurses' and the stark realities of wartime, may be too violent for younger reader under 11 or 12 years old.

Ultimately, the novel serves to highlight the resilience of characters like Vivian Bullwinkle, whose kindness and strength shine through even in the darkest of times. Davis has created a character who is a worthy role model for younger readers and is a heartfelt tribute to the unsung heroism of women and nurses during wartime. Davis's portrayal of Vivian Bullwinkle as a mentor and friend resonates deeply, offering a testament to her enduring legacy of courage and compassion.

The novel emphasises that we do learn from history: the beauty of human resilience, sacrifice for our fellow human being and the importance of human connection. I loved the book and think it will be easily accessible for Middle School readers.
Publisher: Freemantle Press
ISBN: 9781760993733
Format: Paerback
Publication: 2024
Ages: 11+
Themes: Sacrifice, Human Connection, Courage